A few episodes ago, I talked about keeping the human in the front office and AI in the back office. In this episode, I want to come back to that, because there's a grey area in the middle that I think a lot of businesses are getting wrong right now. It's the automated message, the chatbot, the form and the follow-up that goes out on autopilot.
Done well, these things save hours. Done badly, they quietly push customers away.
Let me give you 2 examples from my own life recently.
The first was HP. I was on an ink subscription with them, and I'd gone through WhatsApp because I wanted to speak to somebody, and that's the only way their customer service works. Every time I started a conversation, it had no idea who I was. It asked for my first name, last name, email and the serial number of the printer, all over again. We'd go back and forth and finally sort something out. Then if I had one more question, even right at the end of that conversation, we'd start the whole process all over again.
At no point did that feel like being looked after. It felt like being processed.
The second example was completely different. I rang a local garage to book my car in for a service. The voice on the phone asked what car I drove and when I'd like to bring it in, then confirmed the booking. Then it asked if I had any other questions, and said it would transfer me to a member of the team.
Only then did I realise the whole thing had been an AI voice, and honestly, it was brilliant. It was quick, it was clear, and it got the job done. Being able to then speak to a real person about my car mattered to me as well.
So what's the difference between those 2 experiences? The garage used automation to triage. It handled the simple, repetitive part, then handed me to a human the moment I needed one. HP used automation as a wall. It made me do all the work, it forgot me every time, and there was no easy way through to a person.
Let me add something to that. The next time I rang the garage, I knew it was an AI. It asked me who I was, and from my phone number and my name it came back with, "Do you want to talk about your Tesla again, Ant?" It remembered the car I'd brought in and used it in the conversation. Genius.
That's the line I want to draw. Let automation triage people and gather the basics, and handle the routine stuff like checking a calendar and making appointments. Then let the human serve them.
There's another problem I see in a lot of growing businesses. Once you've got a bigger team, lots of customers and things are growing, a quiet problem starts to creep in. Automations and bots get set up in a hurry, often by someone who has since moved on. The messages are generic and off-brand, and they sound like nobody in particular. Then a warm prospect gets one of those emails, feels like a number, and goes off and buys from somebody else. Nobody in the business even knows it happened.
That's revenue leaking through a system nobody's looking at.
So here are 3 simple checks for your own automations.
First, read every message out loud. Does it sound like you? Would it sound human if the customer could hear it? If the answer's no, rewrite it in your own brand voice.
Second, make sure your systems remember people. If a customer has given you their details once, they should never have to repeat them. Nothing says "we don't know you" faster than asking for an email address you've already got.
Third, build an easy exit to a human. Every automated sequence should have a clear point where someone can say, "I'd like to talk to a person," and actually reach one.
As a bonus, put someone's name next to each automation. When it's owned, it gets checked. When nobody owns it, it drifts.
Used well, automation and AI can make a small team feel much bigger and more responsive, and customers will love it. Just remember that every message a customer reads is part of your brand, whether a person typed it or a system sent it.
See you in the next episode.
If you'd like to talk more, email me at cmo@anthodges.com. Subscribe wherever you're listening, and find every past episode at cmofieldnotes.com.





